Get Atlanta's Favorite Cookies Order Holiday Cookies X
$38/dozen Order Cookies
Orange Ginger Molasses Cookies
Proof of the Pudding Cookies Orange Ginger Molasses Cookies Double Chocolate Hazlenut Cookies Everything Cookies
Limited Time

Get Atlanta's favorite cookie.

POP Cookie Gift Boxes

Pick from three crowd-tested amazing flavors. Or get the variety box to try them all!

  • Orange Ginger Molasses – A flavorful cookie that expertly blends the rich warmth of molasses with the zesty brightness of orange and a subtle spiciness of ginger, all topped with a drizzle of sweet icing in one delectable bite.
  • Double Chocolate Hazelnut – This delectable cookie combines the best of both worlds, marrying the richness of double chocolate with the toasty, nutty goodness of hazelnuts.
  • Everything Cookie – The Everything Cookie features the perfect fusion of semi-sweet chocolate chips, white chocolate chips, pistachios, craisins, and toasted oats.
  • Variety Box – Four of each flavor.


$2 from every box sold supports Giving Kitchen (valid until December 22, 2023, with no maximum contribution).

Giving Kitchen is a James Beard Foundation Award-winning nonprofit organization that serves food service workers in crisis. To learn more, visit:

How it's made

How it tastes

Give Cookies, Give Back this Holiday Season!

Available for a limited time.

Order cookies

©2023 Proof of the Pudding・PrivacyTermsEmployee Portal・Site by nuphoriq